blog insights

What a non-profit shutting down tells us about AI in the social sector

When non-profits when they shut down, we should pay attention to the assets they produce as public goods and how they can be used to drive impact.

Peter Bull
Co-founder

Benefits Data Trust (BDT), a Philadelphia based non-profit, recently announced that they were ceasing operations. No concrete explanation as to why has yet been made public. I was surprised to hear the news; in particular, because I believe BDT was uniquely poised to make the most of the AI transformation coming to the sector.

BDT connected hundreds of thousands of Americans to government benefits they were eligible for. Programs like SNAP and Medicaid have complex administrative rules that are difficult to understand and comply with, especially for those with limited time to navigate the system. By both building awareness through mailers and helping people one-on-one through their call centers, BDT ensured that vulnerable populations received these benefits.

You may think it makes sense that they are ceasing operations. Call centers and mailers are a previous generation of technology that are expensive to operate. Let the next generation of organizations using social media marketing, robocalling, and AI take up the mantle. This loses sight of how hard making those technologies work can be. The key ingredient in successfully building those tools? Data. Specifically, the data of what help others have needed in the past. We shouldn’t let BDT’s wealth of data and knowledge on constituents, benefits processes, common questions, and where a difference can be made fall by the wayside so new organizations must relearn these lessons—and worse than relearn the lessons, have to recreate twenty years of invaluable data on what works.

BDT was in fact a sector leader in their data and AI investments. They were one of the early organizations to have a data science team, and previous leaders of BDT have talked about how to build a data team in a social sector organization. As an example, I had a great conversation at Good Tech Fest this year with someone working to make FAFSA requirements understandable to first-generation college applicants. We talked about the potential for tools like LLMs to help navigate this complex bureaucracy. When we got down to doing some research, we saw that BDT had already built the tool.

One open question is what happens to the absolute treasure trove of data BDT potentially has at their disposal? Call center and chatbot logs of questions and responses are the kinds of data that AI builders are clamoring for. Especially when those conversations are tied to concrete outcomes. In market-based industries, the assets would be valued and likely sold to an entity that could use them. In a non-profit, what happens to these assets is less clear. It could end up the responsibility of the state attorney general, and I think we can feel relatively confident that finding the best home for the assets of a folding nonprofit is likely not a priority that would get the attention it deserves.

Finally, consider the BDT model for impact. Recently at a dinner for social sector data professionals, a colleague made the point: for most social sector organizations, government is the “exit.” That is, the best—and maybe only way—to scale a transformative intervention is to have it taken up as a government program. This is one of the key structural advantages of the BDT model. They were necessarily more effective than direct service organizations that deliver services for things like food security, healthcare, and education funding because the actual services were underwritten by the government. BDT ensured people could get these services. In fact, BDT reported $450 in benefits delivered for every $1 they spent.

I have no special knowledge about what happened at BDT. Maybe it was mismanagement, scandal, or just lack of funder interest. What I do know is that as a sector, we need to pay attention to the things happening at BDT that we desperately need more of: investment in data as an asset, leveraging AI for driving the efficiency of our missions, and focusing on the service gaps where we can multiply impact.

No matter what happened, we should be steadfast about supporting organizations like BDT to thrive in the sector. Losing their experience and their data impoverishes the AI tools that should be transformative.

Tags

Stay updated

Join our newsletter or follow us for the latest on our social impact projects, data science competitions and open source work.

There was a problem. Please try again.
Subscribe successful!
Protected by reCAPTCHA. The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Latest posts

All posts

community

Community Spotlight: Paola Ruiz, Néstor González, Daniel Crovo

The Community Spotlight features fantastic members from our DrivenData community. Three members of the IGCPHARMA team, Paola Ruiz, Néstor González, and Daniel Crovo talk to us about data science, drug discovery, diverse databases and more!

community

Community Spotlight: Kirill Brodt

The Community Spotlight features fantastic members from our DrivenData community. Kirill Brodt, a doctoral student in computer graphics at the University of Montreal, talks animation, pose estimation, and data science challenges.

case studies

A production application to support survivors of human trafficking

DrivenData developed Freedom Lifemap, a digital tool designed to support survivors of human trafficking on their journey toward reintegration and independence

insights

Life beyond the leaderboard

What happens to winning solutions after a machine learning competition?

insights

(Tech) Infrastructure Week for the Nonprofit Sector

Reflections on how to build data and AI infrastructure in the social sector that serves the needs of nonprofits and their beneficiaries.

winners

Meet the winners of Phase 2 of the PREPARE Challenge

Learn about how winners detected cognitive decline using speech recordings and social determinants of health survey data

insights

AI sauce on everything: Reflections on ASU+GSV 2025

Data, evaltuation, product iteration, and public goods: reflections on the ASU+GSV Summit 2025.

resources

Open-source packages for using speech data in ML

Overview of key open-source packages for extracting features from voice data to support ML applications

tutorial

Getting started with LLMs: a benchmark for the 'What's Up, Docs?' challenge

An introduction to using large language models via the benchmark to a document summarization challenge.

winners

Meet the Winners of the Goodnight Moon, Hello Early Literacy Screening Challenge

Learn about the results and winning methods from the early literacy screening challenge.

resources

Where to find a data job for a good cause

Finding data jobs for good causes can be difficult. Learn strategies, job lists, and tips to find organizations with open positions working on causes you care about.

winners

Meet the Winners of the Youth Mental Health Narratives Challenge

Learn about the winning solutions from the Youth Mental Health Challenge Automated Abstraction and Novel Variables Tracks

winners

Meet the winners of the Forecast and Final Prize Stages of the Water Supply Forecast Rodeo

Learn about the winners and winning solutions from the final stages of the Water Supply Forecast Rodeo.

insights

10 takeaways from 10 years of data science for social good

This year DrivenData celebrates our 10th birthday! We've spent the past decade working to use data science and AI for social good. Here are some lessons we've learned along the way.

tutorial

Goodnight Moon, Hello Early Literacy Screening Benchmark

In this guest post from the MIT Gabrieli Lab, we'll show you how to get started with the literacy screening challenge!

tutorial

Youth Mental Health: Automated Abstraction Benchmark

Learn how to process text narratives using open-source LLMs for the Youth Mental Health: Automated Abstraction challenge

winners

Meet the winners of Phase 1 of the PREPARE Challenge

Learn about the top datasets sourced for Phase 1 of the PREPARE Challenge.

resources

Teaching with DrivenData Competitions

Inspiration and resources for teaching students data science, machine learning, and AI skills with DrivenData competitions.

insights

What a non-profit shutting down tells us about AI in the social sector

When non-profits when they shut down, we should pay attention to the assets they produce as public goods and how they can be used to drive impact.

winners

Meet the winners of the Pose Bowl challenge

Learn about the top solutions submitted for the Pose Bowl: Spacecraft Detection and Pose Estimation Challenge.

Work with us to build a better world

Learn more about how our team is bringing the transformative power of data science and AI to organizations tackling the world's biggest challenges.